Fired for heroism?

There was a provocative headline in the July 28, 2009 edition of the Austin TX paper recently: “Randalls employee fired for chasing theft suspect.” It seems that a young brute grabbed a woman’s purse while she was shopping in a Randalls grocery store. Troy Schafer,...

The Middle Rating — A “C” Student?

A lot of people think that getting middle rating in their company’s performance appraisal system is the same as getting a C in school. That’s a bad analogy. Here’s why comparing an organization’s 5-level rating scale to the A-B-C-D-F grading system used in schools is...

How to rate the fully satisfactory performer

Probably the toughest call that managers have to make is how to rate the individual whose performance all year has been fully satisfactory, where there are no important deficiencies that have to be worked on, and where the person has made some contributions that are...

The Myths of Performance Management

The cover story of the September/October 2008 issue of The Conference Board Review is my new article, “Passing Judgment.” In the article I explain that the reason performance appraisal programs fail is typically not because of shoddy forms, bad data and clumsy...